Why Germany is Implementing Strict Immigration Laws After Aschaffenburg Attack?

The shock from the knife attack in Aschaffenburg hits Germany as it heard a boy was dead while an adult, to protect children, was taken by an assailant. The country’s death at such a young age has really sent shockwaves across the nation, provoking grief and introspection. However, the fact that the attacker was a rejected asylum seeker from Afghanistan has made this tragedy a political issue, especially with the German elections coming up. Politicians from the left to the right have responded to public worries, with some demanding tougher immigration policies. And at the very forefront of this discussion is Friedrich Merz, CDU/CSU party leading candidate for chancellor.

Political Reactions

Friedrich Merz emphasized that German immigration policies needed to undergo drastic change in the aftermath of the attack. Merz pledged that, within days of becoming chancellor, he would send rejected asylum seekers to detention centers and step up controls on the country’s borders. He promised to turn away people entering the country illegally while claiming asylum or protection under international laws at Germany’s borders.

The ideas of Merz have come to appeal to parts of voters to establish definitive security measures in public life. His party, CDU/CSU, is at the moment a comfortable lead in the polls, lending credence to his words. But that’s just wishful thinking. It would not be that easy to implement changes. In fact, a Chancellor in Germany cannot issue executive orders like the American President and implement them without any compromise. Every new policy proposed would have to pass through the Bundestag, the federal parliament. This process is full of debates, votes, and negotiations with other political parties, often bringing about compromises.

Coalition Challenge

Germany’s system of governance is established on coalition politics sprouting from the pursuit to ensure no single party will ever exercise absolute power. Even if Merz becomes chancellor, he would need to form a coalition government to have laws passed. For the moment, Merz has already ruled out coalition options with the far-right Alternative for Germany party, which supports many of the immigration policies Merz wants to introduce. Most likely, then, Merz will have to negotiate with either the Social Democrats or the Greens, both of whom have sharply attacked his proposed reform plans.

The SPD and Greens are arguing that parts of Merz’s policies are unconstitutional and in violation of European Union law. They emphasize Germany’s legal and moral obligation to protect those seeking asylum and to respect international treaties on human rights. The entrenched ideological difference makes this a difficult request for Merz to overcome. The chancellor of Germany does not have the power to implement these reforms without coalition partners supporting him.

But perhaps as a result of these challenges, Merz already expressed his intent to act when he recently submitted a set of migration proposals to the Bundestag for debate and voting. This demonstrates that his party will not wait until after elections to start applying pressure for change. In a very controversial and rather key move, Merz has suggested that he may rely on a vote from the AfD to pass his measures, even though he publicly distances himself from the party. This strategy has many raising an eyebrow and criticizing opponents who claim that he sacrifices his principles for political gain.

Broader Implications

The Aschaffenburg attack made it obvious how complex and even polarizing German immigration debate may be. “The public’s safety is just a valid cause for concern that critics have raised; however, with the CDU/CSU’s proposals undermining the very principle of the foundation of the Constitution and violating regulations set by the EU, reactionaries are a danger to Germany, a nation founded on human rights and refuge.”.

Most importantly, the debate is being played against the historical backdrop of Germany. It has been the home of immigrants and refugees for many years, especially since that 2015 migration crisis when Chancellor Angela Merkel famously declared, “We can do this.” However, in doing so, it created political divisions within the country where some people called for strict controls, while others are now asking for more open policies.

The CDU/CSU’s new proposals are widely perceived as being caught between the war of national security and the battle of humanitarian responsibility. While people wonder if Merz really addresses the cause of such an attack or whether this is purely a political strategy to attract the voters, people are of the opinion that reform immigration policy is comprehensive in all dimensions-inclusion, education, and asylum, rather than mere border enforcement.

Future Ahead

Immigration will likely continue to be at the heart of the debate as Germany approaches its elections. The tragedy in Aschaffenburg put the debate into sharp focus, causing both policymakers and voters to reflect on the nation’s values and priorities. Friedrich Merz’s proposals may appeal to those seeking immediate action, but their feasibility and long-term consequences remain uncertain.

For Merz, the hurdle is thus deeper than electoral victory; it will also involve mastering the complexities of coalition politics and constitutional law. Whether the proposals become a success at the Bundestag will largely depend on his convincing coalition partners and more members of the public of their necessity and legal possibility.

For Germany as a whole, this debate is an opportunity to rethink the approach of this country to immigration in a balance between security and compassion. The Aschaffenburg attack shall leave an immeasurable impression on the country but has already marked the time for thoughtful, inclusive policymaking. Therefore, as this country moves further, its policymakers have to deal with solutions in which they meet the commitments regarding human rights through Germany while relating to the fears of its inhabitants.

Read More at How to Abroad

Germany Elections 2025: Major Parties and their Promises

Germany’s Tax Plans for 2025

Deutschlandticket to increase to 58 Euros per month Starting in 2025